The Shelf · Who decides
Quantifying reputation and success in art
Science, vol. 362, pp. 825–829
Samuel P. Fraiberger, Roberta Sinatra, Magnus Resch, Christoph Riedl and Albert-László Barabási
Academic · Paper · 2018 · Science (American Association for the Advancement of Science)
The argument in one line
Where an artist first shows predicts their whole career. The art world behaves like a network in which early access to the central institutions decides who rises.
Who is talking
Network scientists, not art historians, with half a million careers of data. One co-author, Magnus Resch, is an art-market entrepreneur who sells data and services to collectors and galleries.
What it argues
- The data. Exhibition and auction histories of about half a million artists, 1980–2016: nearly 500,000 gallery shows in about 16,000 galleries, nearly 290,000 museum shows in about 7,500 museums, and over 127,000 auctions.
- A map of prestige. Institutions are linked when they show the same artists. The most central institutions in that network are the prestigious ones. Prestige is measured, not assumed.
- The start decides. Artists whose first shows were at central institutions mostly kept that access for life and rarely dropped out. Artists who began on the periphery mostly stayed there or left the field.
- Path dependence. A model of careers shows strong dependence on history: where you have shown decides where you can show next, and that decides the price.
Claims and the record
What the paper claims, set against a public source or this site’s own figures.
Early access to prestigious institutions causes lifelong success.Partly
The paper shows a strong association in exhibition records, and a model that fits it. It is not an experiment, so it cannot fully separate the institutions picking future stars from the institutions making them. The authors make the network the explanation, and that is the reading most coverage repeats.
Read it for
The numbers behind Bourdieu's consecration and Thompson's branded dealers. It is short and free to read.
What this summary rests on
from reviews Not yet checked against the text. Written from the publisher’s description, reviews and the public record, listed below. The summary is in our own words. No passage of the paper is reproduced.
Spotted an error? It goes on the corrections log.