The Shelf · From inside the room

The Mona Lisa Curse

Channel 4 documentary, 75 minutes

Robert Hughes (presenter); directed by Mandy Chang

Insider · Film · 2008 · Oxford Film and Television for Channel 4

The argument in one line

Big money has damaged how art is made, controlled and experienced. The curse began when the Mona Lisa toured as a celebrity in 1963 and art became something you queue to photograph.

Who is talking

For three decades Time magazine's art critic, and author of The Shock of the New. This was his last television essay, an angry one, made as the market peaked.

What it argues

  1. The Mona Lisa as a celebrity. The painting's 1963 visit to the United States drew huge crowds who saw it for a few seconds each. For Hughes that marked the moment art became an event to attend rather than a thing to look at.
  2. Artists as businessmen. Warhol, Hirst and others are presented as brand managers, and their fortunes as a measure of the art world's values rather than of their art's.
  3. Museums as brands. Museums market themselves like companies, with franchises and blockbusters. Hughes says this changes what they show and how people look.
  4. Collectors as investors. Buyers treat art as an asset to be stored or flipped, which Hughes regards as contempt for the work itself.

What has changed

Made in 2008 at the top of the boom, which ended weeks after broadcast. It won the 2009 International Emmy for arts programming.

Read it for

The case against, at full volume, from a critic who loved art. It is hard to find legally, so look for a broadcaster's or library copy.

What this summary rests on

from reviews Not yet checked against the text. Written from the publisher’s description, reviews and the public record, listed below. The summary is in our own words. No passage of the film is reproduced.

Spotted an error? It goes on the corrections log.