The Shelf · Who decides

High Price

Art Between the Market and Celebrity Culture

Isabelle Graw

Academic · Book · 2010 · Sternberg Press (English edition; German original 2008)

The argument in one line

Market value and artistic value are not the same, but the market cannot do without the other. A price has to be backed by critics, curators and art history, and that is the only check the market has.

Who is talking

An art theorist (Städelschule, Frankfurt) and co-founder of the journal Texte zur Kunst. She writes from inside the critical establishment that she says the market depends on, and so has a stake in its importance.

What it argues

  1. Two values. Every work carries a market value and a symbolic value. The two are not the same, and the market is always borrowing credibility from the second to justify the first.
  2. Celebrity. Since the 1990s, the market has fused with celebrity culture. The artist's persona, life and visibility are sold with the work, and an artist who is famous for being famous can command prices criticism never backed.
  3. No outside. Graw rejects the comforting idea that some art is pure and outside the market. Critics and artists are inside it too. The question is how much independence they keep.
  4. Criticism as a check. If the market needs symbolic value, then criticism still has power, but only if it is willing to say no. A criticism that only endorses becomes advertising.

What has changed

Written around the 2008 crash. Its targets, the celebrity artist and the market as spectacle, are still current.

Read it for

The argument that criticism still matters, from a critic. Weigh it against Thornton's fieldwork and Steyerl's pessimism.

What this summary rests on

from reviews Not yet checked against the text. Written from the publisher’s description, reviews and the public record, listed below. The summary is in our own words. No passage of the book is reproduced.

Spotted an error? It goes on the corrections log.