The Shelf · Who decides
Distinction
A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste
Pierre Bourdieu
Academic · Book · 1979 · Éditions de Minuit (French, 1979); Harvard University Press and Routledge (English, 1984)
The argument in one line
Taste is not personal. It is learned, unevenly, by class. Liking the right art marks who you are and keeps others out.
Who is talking
The same sociologist as The Rules of Art, writing from large surveys of French households in the 1960s. It is an empirical book, not an essay.
What it argues
- Taste classifies. What people say they like in art, music and food sorts them by class and education with remarkable regularity. Each judgement of taste places the person making it.
- Cultural capital. Knowing how to look at art, and feeling at ease in a gallery, is a resource learned at home and school. It can be turned into status and money, as other capital can, and is passed on in a similar way.
- Form over function. The dominant classes prize detachment and the form of a work. Other classes ask what the work is for and what it shows. The first stance is then treated as the legitimate one.
- The point of distinction. Distinction works by being scarce. Once a taste spreads it loses its value, and those at the top move on, which is one of the engines of fashion in art.
What has changed
The surveys are of 1960s France. Later research argues that today's elites are omnivores who like everything rather than only the highbrow. Even so, it is the way of liking, not the list of likes, that still marks class.
Read it for
Why buying art is never only buying art. It explains the collector half of Thompson's positional good.
What this summary rests on
from reviews Not yet checked against the text. Written from the publisher’s description, reviews and the public record, listed below. The summary is in our own words. No passage of the book is reproduced.
Spotted an error? It goes on the corrections log.