The Shelf · Follow the money
The $12 Million Stuffed Shark
The Curious Economics of Contemporary Art
Don Thompson
Non-fiction · Book · 2008 · Aurum Press (UK), Palgrave Macmillan (US)
The argument in one line
Nobody pays millions for the object. They pay for the brands standing behind it: the dealer, the auction house, the collector who owned it before, and the museum that showed it.
Who is talking
A business-school economist: Emeritus Professor of Marketing and Strategy at the Schulich School of Business, York University, Toronto, who has also taught at Harvard Business School and the LSE. An outsider by training, he built the book from interviews with dealers, auctioneers and collectors. So it is largely the market's own account of itself, read by a sceptic, and the people interviewed had their own reasons to talk.
What it argues
- The question in the title. Damien Hirst's tiger shark in formaldehyde was rotting when it changed hands. Hirst later replaced it with a fresh shark, and the buyer paid for that too. If the physical thing can be swapped out, the money was buying something else. The book sets out to name what.
- Branding is the product. Thompson's central idea is the brand. A branded dealer, a branded auction house, a branded collector and a branded museum each lend a work their reputation. A buyer who cannot judge quality, and most cannot, buys the reassurance instead. Paying a fortune through a famous gallery is the safe choice: if the work turns out to be a mistake, the buyer at least made it in respectable company.
- A positional good. At the top, art works like membership. A purchase admits the buyer to dinners, previews, museum boards and the opening hours of a fair. Being allowed to buy is itself rationed: dealers keep waiting lists and choose who gets a work, and the choosing is part of what is being sold.
- The auction as theatre. Evening sales are staged. The order of lots, the opening bids, the auctioneer's pacing and bids called from the room before the reserve is reached all build momentum. Guarantees and pre-arranged bidders mean that some of the outcome is settled before the sale begins.
- Defending a price. Dealers have a stake in their artists' auction results. A work that fails to sell at auction drags down the gallery's asking prices, so dealers and their collectors will bid to stop it failing. The public price is then partly a price the dealer paid to protect.
- Price as a signal of quality. In a market with no agreed measure of quality, the price stands in for one. A high price persuades the next buyer that the work must be important, and that is how a price climbs.
- Everyone else. Under the branded tier is a large mass of working artists whose work barely sells, and galleries that open and close. The headline prices describe a few dozen names, not the trade.
Claims and the record
What the book claims, set against a public source or this site’s own figures.
The shark sold for $12 million.Unconfirmed
The price was never disclosed. When Charles Saatchi sold the work to the hedge-fund manager Steven A. Cohen in 2004, reports put it at $8 million to $12 million. In 1991 the whole work cost about £50,000 to make, the shark £6,000 of it. The title quotes the highest reported figure.
Wikipedia: The Physical Impossibility of Death in the Mind of Someone Living
Part of the result is arranged before the auction begins.Holds
Yes, and it is partly disclosed. The houses mark lots with a guarantee or an irrevocable bid with a catalogue symbol. The guarantor can still bid and is paid a fee for carrying the risk, whether or not they win. The symbol tells you an arrangement exists. It does not tell you who made it or what they are paid.
Apollo: Handle with care, the problem with auction guarantees · The Art Newspaper: how third-party partners helped Christie's record-breaking New York auction (2015)
The branded auction house charges for its brand.Holds
It does, and the charge is the buyer's premium. At Christie's and Sotheby's today the premium starts at 28% of the hammer price, before VAT and the artist's resale right. The Final Bill on this site works out the full sum for any hammer price.
What has changed
Written at the top of the 2007–08 boom, just before the crash. The names and prices are those of that moment. The mechanics it describes, branding, guarantees and dealers defending prices, have only become more formal since.
Read it for
The clearest single explanation of why price and quality separate at the top of the market. It is anecdotal, not statistical, and it trusts its interviewees more than a sceptic should.
What this summary rests on
from reviews Not yet checked against the text. Written from the publisher’s description, reviews and the public record, listed below. The summary is in our own words. No passage of the book is reproduced.
- Penguin Random House Canada: Don Thompson, author page
- Palgrave Macmillan: Don Thompson, author page
- Marginal Revolution: Tyler Cowen on the book (2008)
Spotted an error? It goes on the corrections log.