The Shelf · Follow the money

The Orange Balloon Dog

Bubbles, Turmoil and Avarice in the Contemporary Art Market

Don Thompson

Non-fiction · Book · 2017 · Douglas & McIntyre (Canada, 2017), Aurum Press (UK, 2018)

The argument in one line

Ten years after the shark, the top of the market behaves less like collecting and more like a financial market, with the psychology of one, and Thompson asks whether it is a bubble.

Who is talking

The same author as The $12 Million Stuffed Shark, now a well-known market commentator with good access. That access is the book's strength and its limit: the sources are again mostly people with a stake in the market.

What it argues

  1. The dog in the title. Jeff Koons's Balloon Dog (Orange) sold at Christie's in New York in November 2013 for $58.4 million, then the highest auction price for a work by a living artist. Thompson uses the sale to ask what buyers think they are buying when a mirror-polished steel sculpture is one of an edition of five, each in a different colour.
  2. Buyers are not rational. The book borrows from behavioural economics. Fear of missing out, anchoring on the last record and the rivalry of a bidding contest drive prices more than any assessment of the work. Thompson shows how houses and dealers nudge buyers by framing, sequencing and controlling access.
  3. Art in storage. A growing share of top-end art is bought and never hung. It goes into freeports: bonded, tax-suspended warehouses where a work can change owners repeatedly without leaving its crate. On this view art is a store of value, kept in the dark.
  4. New money, new centres. New buyers in China, the Gulf and elsewhere in Asia have changed who sets prices. Auction houses and fairs followed them to Hong Kong and beyond, and competition between centres now shapes value as much as any critic.
  5. Is it a bubble?. Thompson weighs the signs: rapid resale of young artists' work, art bought with borrowed money, and prices running ahead of any institutional judgement. He stops short of predicting a crash but makes the case that much of the top end is speculation.

Claims and the record

What the book claims, set against a public source or this site’s own figures.

$58.4 million is the auction record for a living artist.Out of date

It was in 2013, and it no longer is. David Hockney's Portrait of an Artist (Pool with Two Figures) made $90.3 million in November 2018, and Koons's own Rabbit made $91.1 million in May 2019.

Wikipedia: Balloon Dog · Wikipedia: Rabbit (Koons)

Freeports let art change hands out of sight of regulators.Out of date

That is out of date in the UK. Since 10 January 2020 anyone in the UK who trades art, or runs a freeport that stores it, at €10,000 or more must register with HMRC and check who their customers are. Elsewhere it depends on the jurisdiction. The EU applied the same rule through its Fifth Anti-Money Laundering Directive.

GOV.UK: Money laundering supervision for art market participants

The top of the market is a bubble.Still open

Still open. The market has had bad years since, but it has not collapsed. The latest annual report, for 2025, has public auction sales up 9% to $20.7 billion. That is one number, and Market size on this site shows what it covers.

Near Mint: Market size

What has changed

The freeport chapter predates the 2020 money-laundering rules, and the living-artist record it builds on has been broken twice.

Read it for

The financial turn of the 2010s, from the inside. It is less lively than the first book and more of an economist's survey. Read the shark book first.

What this summary rests on

from reviews Not yet checked against the text. Written from the publisher’s description, reviews and the public record, listed below. The summary is in our own words. No passage of the book is reproduced.

Spotted an error? It goes on the corrections log.