The Shelf · Who decides

The Rules of Art

Genesis and Structure of the Literary Field

Pierre Bourdieu

Academic · Book · 1992 · Éditions du Seuil (French, 1992); Polity and Stanford University Press (English, 1996)

The argument in one line

Art is a field with its own reversed economy. Selling well can cost an artist prestige, and the belief in the solitary genius hides the fact that the field itself makes the value.

Who is talking

A sociologist at the Collège de France, writing theory grounded in the history of nineteenth-century Paris (Flaubert and Manet's world). He is the source of most of the vocabulary the other books on this shelf use, whether they credit it or not.

What it argues

  1. The economic world reversed. In the most prestigious part of the art world, commercial success is suspect. Being disinterested is what earns credit, and that credit can later be turned into money. So the money comes, but slowly, and it has to look as though it was never the point.
  2. Two markets. Every art world has a slow, restricted circuit, where artists produce for other artists, critics and curators, and a fast, large-scale one producing for buyers. Each looks down on the other, and value moves from the first to the second.
  3. Who creates the creator?. The romantic idea of the genius hides the work done by dealers, critics, publishers, academies and museums in deciding who counts as one. Bourdieu calls the result consecration, a word borrowed from the church on purpose.
  4. Positions and position-taking. An artist's style is also a move in a game against other artists, defined by what it refuses. The avant-garde of one generation becomes the establishment the next one attacks.

What has changed

The examples are nineteenth-century French literature and painting. Bourdieu wrote before the global auction market. The mechanism still describes the gallery system closely.

Read it for

The theory underneath everything else here. It is dense, so read Thornton or Perry first and come back to it.

What this summary rests on

from reviews Not yet checked against the text. Written from the publisher’s description, reviews and the public record, listed below. The summary is in our own words. No passage of the book is reproduced.

Spotted an error? It goes on the corrections log.