The Shelf · Follow the money
Why Are Artists Poor?
The Exceptional Economy of the Arts
Hans Abbing
Academic · Book · 2002 · Amsterdam University Press (free open-access edition)
The argument in one line
Most artists are poor because the arts run on myths that make poverty look noble. The myths keep too many people entering a field that pays almost none of them, and subsidy makes it worse.
Who is talking
An economist who is also a practising visual artist. He writes from both sides of the studio door and is unsentimental about both.
What it argues
- The paradox. Artists' incomes are far below those of people with similar education, yet there is never a shortage of new artists. In any other trade low pay would thin the supply. In the arts it does not.
- The myths that keep it going. Art is said to be sacred, the artist selfless, and money beside the point. Those beliefs make it shameful to ask about pay and admirable to work for nothing. Abbing argues they serve the people who buy and fund art more than the people who make it.
- A winner-takes-all lottery. Rewards are extremely skewed: a few artists earn fortunes and most earn little. Young artists overrate their chances, much like gamblers, and the rare stars keep the queue long.
- Subsidy deepens poverty. His most provocative claim is that grants and donations raise the number of artists more than they raise artists' incomes. More people are kept in the field at the same low pay, so total poverty grows.
- A gift economy. The arts sit half inside the market and half in a gift economy of donations, sponsorship and unpaid work. That mix is what makes the economics exceptional, and what makes it so hard to fix.
Claims and the record
What the book claims, set against a public source or this site’s own figures.
The market rewards a few artists and almost nobody else.Holds
It holds wherever there is data. In the UK the one route by which artists share in their own rising prices is the artist's resale right. It pays only on resales of €1,000 or more through the trade and is capped at €12,500 a sale, so it mostly helps the artists who are already succeeding.
What has changed
The examples are Dutch and from around 2000, when Dutch subsidy for visual artists was unusually generous. The argument travels.
Read it for
The economics of the people the rest of this shelf leaves out. It is free to read online.
What this summary rests on
from reviews Not yet checked against the text. Written from the publisher’s description, reviews and the public record, listed below. The summary is in our own words. No passage of the book is reproduced.
Spotted an error? It goes on the corrections log.