The Shelf · Follow the money

Art of the Deal

Contemporary Art in a Global Financial Market

Noah Horowitz

Academic · Book · 2011 · Princeton University Press

The argument in one line

Contemporary art became a financial asset, and even work made to resist the market, such as video, installation and performance, was turned into something that could be sold.

Who is talking

An art historian writing an academic book, who then went to work for the trade he described. He later ran gallery and dealer services at Sotheby's, was Art Basel's Director Americas from 2015 to 2021, and became its chief executive in November 2022. That does not make the book wrong, but readers should know it.

What it argues

  1. Art as an asset class. From the 2000s, investors treated art like other assets: art funds, price indices, lending against art. Horowitz explains how investors speculate in art, and how badly most art funds actually performed.
  2. Selling the unsellable. Video, installation and performance were meant to escape the market. The market answered with limited editions, certificates and artists' instructions. A work you cannot hang became a work you can own.
  3. The experience economy. Fairs, biennials and museum spectacles made art an experience as well as an object. The market sells access to that experience along with the work.
  4. After 2008. The book was written as the first contemporary-art bubble deflated. It asks which of the new financial habits would survive the crash. Most did.

Claims and the record

What the book claims, set against a public source or this site’s own figures.

Art is an asset class like any other.Partly

It is treated as one, but it does not behave like one. There are no dividends, ownership costs are high and selling is slow. At auction the buyer's premium starts at 28% at the two largest houses, and the seller pays a fee too. An investment that loses a quarter of its value in fees before the hammer falls is not like a share.

Near Mint: The Final Bill

What has changed

A paperback edition (2014) added a postscript on the years after 2011.

Read it for

How a market built itself around art that was made against it. Read it alongside the author's later career.

What this summary rests on

from reviews Not yet checked against the text. Written from the publisher’s description, reviews and the public record, listed below. The summary is in our own words. No passage of the book is reproduced.

Spotted an error? It goes on the corrections log.