The Shelf · Follow the money

Talking Prices

Symbolic Meanings of Prices on the Market for Contemporary Art

Olav Velthuis

Academic · Book · 2005 · Princeton University Press

The argument in one line

A gallery price is not just a number. It is a message about the artist, the dealer and the buyer, and dealers set prices for what the message says.

Who is talking

An economic sociologist at the University of Amsterdam. The book grew out of his doctoral research: interviews with dealers in New York and Amsterdam. It is the only book here based on systematic fieldwork in the primary market.

What it argues

  1. Prices as a language. Dealers use prices to say things: that an artist is rising, that a collector is serious, that a gallery is the right kind of gallery. A price that says the wrong thing is avoided even when it would clear the stock.
  2. Front room and back room. The gallery is built to keep art and commerce apart. The front room looks like a museum and the back office like a business. Prices are rarely on the wall and are given only when asked.
  3. Prices do not go down. A dealer who cuts an artist's prices tells the market the career is failing. So primary prices are kept flat when demand falls. The work goes unsold, or is sold at a quiet discount that never appears on the price list.
  4. Rules of thumb. Dealers price by size, by medium, and by the artist's last price. Prices climb in small, regular steps, and a sudden leap is treated as dangerous.
  5. Who gets to buy. The same price is not offered to everyone. Museums and well-known collectors get discounts and first refusal because where a work ends up is part of what makes the next one valuable.

Claims and the record

What the book claims, set against a public source or this site’s own figures.

Prices for an artist rarely fall in public.Holds

On the gallery's price list, yes. At auction they fall all the time. The resale market prints what the primary market hides, and the band under £25k on this site shows how often lots sell below the house's own estimate.

Near Mint: What sold under £25k, estimate against result

Read it for

The best account of how a gallery decides a price, and why it will not lower one. It is academic but readable.

What this summary rests on

from reviews Not yet checked against the text. Written from the publisher’s description, reviews and the public record, listed below. The summary is in our own words. No passage of the book is reproduced.

Spotted an error? It goes on the corrections log.